Distinct Patterns of Brain Activity Characterise Lexical Activation and Competition in Spoken Word Production


According to a prominent theory of language production, concepts activate multiple associated words in memory, which enter into competition for selection. However, only a few electrophysiological studies have identified brain responses reflecting competition. Here, we report a magnetoencephalography study in which the activation of competing words was manipulated by presenting pictures (e.g., dog) with distractor words. The distractor and picture name were semantically related (cat), unrelated (pin), or identical (dog). Related distractors are stronger competitors to the picture name because they receive additional activation from the picture relative to other distractors. Picture naming times were longer with related than unrelated and identical distractors. Phase-locked and non-phase-locked activity were distinct but temporally related. Phase-locked activity in left temporal cortex, peaking at 400 ms, was larger on unrelated than related and identical trials, suggesting differential activation of alternative words by the picture-word stimuli. Non-phase-locked activity between roughly 350-650 ms (4-10 Hz) in left superior frontal gyrus was larger on related than unrelated and identical trials, suggesting differential resolution of the competition among the alternatives, as reflected in the naming times. These findings characterise distinct patterns of activity associated with lexical activation and competition, supporting the theory that words are selected by competition.

In: PLoS ONE, (9), 2, e88674

Rejection history (my worst experience):

Journal Outcome Reason
PNAS Rejected after major revisions submitted (Reviewer #1 accepted, Reviewer #2 rejected) Clearly biased reviewer had major concerns with names of our contrasts, all the interpretation, etc.
Cerebral Cortex We retracted after second round of major revisions and additional reviewer added on the way Every time a completely new set of critique